Develop Reference

Understanding the concept of super?

I'm having trouble wrapping my head around the concept of super(). Java Tutorials gives this example:
public class Superclass {
public void printMethod() {
System.out.println("Printed in Superclass.");
}
}
public class Subclass extends Superclass {
// overrides printMethod in Superclass
public void printMethod() {
super.printMethod();
System.out.println("Printed in Subclass");
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
Subclass s = new Subclass();
s.printMethod();
}
}
But if I am overriding the printMethod, why do I need to invoke the Superclass method? Why can't I just write whatever in the Subclass method of printMethod() and just move on?

There is absolutely no need to call the super.
It just helps you to call the logic contained within super class method if you require that.
Many times you want the exact logic to run and then provide your additional logic.
Overriding always does not mean providing brand new logic. Sometimes you want to provide a slight variation. For e.g., if the method returns a value, then you call the super class method and get the value. Then you make some slight modification in that object using logic in the sub class method and return it back to caller.

You can override it. In that case, the parent method is ignored. super() is used if you want the parent method to be executed in the subclass.

This is used to avoid duplicated code. Let's say you have a class:
public class SuperClass() {
private int var1;
private int var2;
private int var3;
public SuperClass() {
var1 = 1;
var2 = 2;
var3 = 3;
}
}
and a subclass:
public class SubClass() {
private int var1;
private int var2;
private int var3;
private int var4;
public SubClass() {
super();
var4 = 4;
}
}
In this example, you are using super() to invoke superclass constructor (constructor are usually used to initialize members) so you can focus on the SubClass members, and you don't have to repeat all the initialization lines (for var1, var2 and var3).

Basically the super class is the upper most level of the program. When you create a new subclass you must "inherit" from the super class using the keyword 'extends'. This does 2 things; It allows you to use any methods created in the super class, in the subclass and it also allows you overwrite methods in the super class. Basically, if you have one method you want to use in a bunch of classes you use the super class to create it and then the sub-classes can just call the method using standard dot notation.

If you just run this program, Inside PrintMethod of the subclass will call to super class "printMethod" (print "Printed in Superclass") and then execute the things you have written in the sub class method(print "Printed in Subclass").
public void printMethod() {
//super.printMethod(); // comment this line
System.out.println("Printed in Subclass");
}
if you run like this, it will print only the things that you have written in the sub class method.
Idea is, If you want use Super class method information in the sub class, then you can call like Super.MethodName().

Clear Explanation :
public static void main(String[] args) {
Subclass s = new Subclass();
s.printMethod();
}
Subclass s = new Subclass();
(i) when we are creating sub class object what wiill happens?
constructor of subclss will be executed
(ii) Do we have any costructor in sub class (Subclass )
if we have dat will execute..
but we are not having so default costructor will excecute
(iii) what default costructor will have?
Subclass (){
super();
}
(iv) what super() will do?
it calls super class contructor
in super class also we are not having constructor so
will execute default constructor
Superclass(){
super();
}
super class of superclass is Object class
so Object class is the super class of evry class in java
so it will creates object of object class..
object of Object class created
|
and comes to its subclass constructor...//step (iv)
Superclass(){
super(); // executed
}
object of Object class created
|
object of Superclass craeted
so super class constuctror execution also completed so
it will creates Object of SuperClass..
then control comes to its subclass conctructor // step (iii)
so Subclass (){
super(); // executed
}
after completion of subclass constructor it creates the object of subclass
*Important point : after completion of constructor execution
Object of thet class will be created*
object of Object class created
|
object of Superclass craeted
|
object of Subclass craeted
all this happened because of Subclass s = new Subclass();
so when you created object of sub class 3 objects are created..
s.printMethod();
now you are calling a method on subclass object
^
printMethod() is there in super class and sub class
when u r calling a method on sub class object what happens?
(i) it will search for that method in outer most objest: Object of Object class
so now printMethod() is not there in object of object class
(ii) Next its searches in next superclass object ie. object of Superclass
object Superclass object having printMethod() method
(iii) so method found...eventhougth method found controll serches in next sub most object is object of subclass object....
(iv) two methos found in two object but it excecutes sub most object method.
so sub most object is Subclass object...
so it executes the subclass printMethod() method.
Note: when we call a method on object it will executes the sub most objects method if ovverriden.....
now our method is....
public void printMethod() {
super.printMethod();
System.out.println("Printed in Subclass");
}
first line in this method is super.printMethod();
by default super ponts to super class object : object of Superclass
object of Superclass .printMethod() is
public void printMethod() {
System.out.println("Printed in Superclass.");
}
so prints :
Printed in Superclass.
next line is : System.out.println("Printed in Subclass");
so it prints : Printed in Subclass
Note : first while creating object it called super class constructor..
now in method called super class method..
Note:
1.if class not having any constructor jvm assigns default constructor as
ClassName(){
super(); calls super class constructor
}
if class alrdy having constructor
the first line of the constructor should be the super() call.
for example: class A{
int variablea;
A(int a){
variablea=a;
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
A a=new A(2);
}
}
in this example
A(int a){
variablea=a;
} code replaces with
A(int a){
super(); by jvm by default
variablea=a;
}

You can use super in a subclass to refer to its immediate superclass. Super has two general forms.
to call the super class's constructor from the subclass
to access a member of the superclass from the subclass
I'm assuming that you are trying to understand the second one.
An example which might make you understand how super helps in referencing members of the super class:
public class Human {
String name;
int age;
public void printDetails() {
System.out.println("Name:"+name);
System.out.println("Age:"+age);
}
}
public class Student extends Human {
int rollNumber;
String grade;
public void printDetails() {
super.printDetails();
System.out.println("Roll Number:"+rollNumber);
System.out.println("Grade:"+grade);
}
public void printNameAgeAndSayGoodMorning(){
super.printDetails();
System.out.println("Good morning!");
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
Student s = new Student();
s.name="MyName";
s.age=27;
s.rollNumber=3;
s.grade="A+";
s.printDetails();
System.out.println(); //just an empty line
s.printNameAgeAndSayGoodMorning();
}
}
I avoided constructors or any getter/setter methods for simplicity.
In this example, do you think you really have to "just write whatever in the Subclass" instead of reusing the printDetails() method available in the super class?

Java Constructor weird behaviour

I've run this code
public class Redimix extends Concrete{
Redimix(){
System.out.println("r ");
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
new Redimix();
}
}
class Concrete extends Sand{
Concrete() { System.out.print("c "); }
private Concrete(String s) { }
}
abstract class Sand{
Sand(){
System.out.print("s ");
}
}
and it printed out s c r but what I was expecting is that only r my question what is the logical explanation for this?
if a parent base class is an abstract class that has a constructor and then we create another class then extend it to the base class (In our Case Concrete extends Sand) and we then create another class then extend it to the concrete class name (In our case redimix) will all constructors from the hierarchy will be called?(from top to bottom)

A constructor of the superclass is always called as the first action of a constructor.
If you do not explicitly invoke a constructor of the superclass, the default constructor (the "no args" one) is implicitly invoked.

That is correct. The parent object's constructor is always called before the childs. This ensures that the object is in a valid state and that the object that has extended another class can always know what state the object is in.
Here is the code that you provided, after the compiler has inserted the implicit constructor calls in on your behave. Note that super(); is always called first.
public class Redimix extends Concrete{
Redimix(){
super();
System.out.println("r ");
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
new Redimix();
}
}
class Concrete extends Sand{
Concrete() { super(); System.out.print("c "); }
private Concrete(String s) { }
}
abstract class Sand{
Sand(){
super(); // invoking the constructor for java.lang.Object
System.out.print("s ");
}
}

In each constructor, parent constructor is also called.

In every constructor, first statement is always super() which is calling super class constructor except for Object class

You need to understand constructor chaining for this. When you make a call to any constructor all the super class constructors are invoked first. In you constructor definition, if you dont have one compiler will add a no argument call to super class constructor something like this : super();
This is because, all the class in the hierarchy must be build before you actual class, because your class is dependent on its super class.
This class to the super class constructor should always be the first statement in your constructor definition because they must be build before this concerned class. So Object class constructor is always the first to be executed.

invoking constructor in java

class A {
A() {
System.out.print("A");
}
}
class B extends A {
B() {
System.out.print("B");
}
}
class C extends B {
C() {
System.out.print("C");
}
}
public class My extends C {
My(){
super();
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
My m = new My();
}
}
Question starts from one Interview Question (what happens when an object is created in Java?)
and answer is...
The constructor for the most derived class is invoked. The first
thing a constructor does is call the consctructor for its
superclasses. This process continues until the constrcutor for
java.lang.Object is called, as java.lang.Object is the base class for
all objects in java. Before the body of the constructor is executed,
all instance variable initializers and initialization blocks are
executed. Then the body of the constructor is executed. Thus, the
constructor for the base class completes first and constructor for the
most derived class completes last.
So, according to above statement, answer should be ABCC, but it showing only ABC. Although, when i'm commenting the super() in derived constructor. Then, output is ABC. Please, help me to figure out, did i misunderstand the above paragraph. ?

No, the answer is ABC
My m = new My();
The above first invokes My class, then a super call is made to its super class i.e., C class, then a super call to B class is made, then a super call to A Class, then a Super call to java.lang.Object as all objects extend java.lang.Object.
Thus the answer is ABC.
You don't really need to explicitly call super() in your My class as it'd be included by the compiler unless you call an overloaded constructor of that class like this(something).

The below code will print ABC
To invoke the constructor of the super class, the compiler will implicitly call the super() in each and every class extending the class, if you are not calling the super construcotr explicitly.

Difference between "this" and"super" keywords in Java

What is the difference between the keywords this and super?
Both are used to access constructors of class right? Can any of you explain?

Lets consider this situation
class Animal {
void eat() {
System.out.println("animal : eat");
}
}
class Dog extends Animal {
void eat() {
System.out.println("dog : eat");
}
void anotherEat() {
super.eat();
}
}
public class Test {
public static void main(String[] args) {
Animal a = new Animal();
a.eat();
Dog d = new Dog();
d.eat();
d.anotherEat();
}
}
The output is going to be
animal : eat
dog : eat
animal : eat
The third line is printing "animal:eat" because we are calling super.eat(). If we called this.eat(), it would have printed as "dog:eat".

super is used to access methods of the base class while this is used to access methods of the current class.
Extending the notion, if you write super(), it refers to constructor of the base class, and if you write this(), it refers to the constructor of the very class where you are writing this code.

this is a reference to the object typed as the current class, and super is a reference to the object typed as its parent class.
In the constructor, this() calls a constructor defined in the current class. super() calls a constructor defined in the parent class. The constructor may be defined in any parent class, but it will refer to the one overridden closest to the current class. Calls to other constructors in this way may only be done as the first line in a constructor.
Calling methods works the same way. Calling this.method() calls a method defined in the current class where super.method() will call the same method as defined in the parent class.

From your question, I take it that you are really asking about the use of this and super in constructor chaining; e.g.
public class A extends B {
public A(...) {
this(...);
...
}
}
versus
public class A extends B {
public A(...) {
super(...);
...
}
}
The difference is simple:
The this form chains to a constructor in the current class; i.e. in the A class.
The super form chains to a constructor in the immediate superclass; i.e. in the B class.

this refers to a reference of the current class.
super refers to the parent of the current class (which called the super keyword).
By doing this, it allows you to access methods/attributes of the current class (including its own private methods/attributes).
super allows you to access public/protected method/attributes of parent(base) class. You cannot see the parent's private method/attributes.

super() & this()
super() - to call parent class constructor.
this() - to call same class constructor.
NOTE:
We can use super() and this() only in constructor not anywhere else, any
attempt to do so will lead to compile-time error.
We have to keep either super() or this() as the first line of the
constructor but NOT both simultaneously.
super & this keyword
super - to call parent class members(variables and methods).
this - to call same class members(variables and methods).
NOTE: We can use both of them anywhere in a class except static areas(static block or method), any
attempt to do so will lead to compile-time error.

this is used to access the methods and fields of the current object. For this reason, it has no meaning in static methods, for example.
super allows access to non-private methods and fields in the super-class, and to access constructors from within the class' constructors only.

When writing code you generally don't want to repeat yourself. If you have an class that can be constructed with various numbers of parameters a common solution to avoid repeating yourself is to simply call another constructor with defaults in the missing arguments. There is only one annoying restriction to this - it must be the first line of the declared constructor. Example:
MyClass()
{
this(default1, default2);
}
MyClass(arg1, arg2)
{
validate arguments, etc...
note that your validation logic is only written once now
}
As for the super() constructor, again unlike super.method() access it must be the first line of your constructor. After that it is very much like the this() constructors, DRY (Don't Repeat Yourself), if the class you extend has a constructor that does some of what you want then use it and then continue with constructing your object, example:
YourClass extends MyClass
{
YourClass(arg1, arg2, arg3)
{
super(arg1, arg2) // calls MyClass(arg1, arg2)
validate and process arg3...
}
}
Additional information:
Even though you don't see it, the default no argument constructor always calls super() first. Example:
MyClass()
{
}
is equivalent to
MyClass()
{
super();
}
I see that many have mentioned using the this and super keywords on methods and variables - all good. Just remember that constructors have unique restrictions on their usage, most notable is that they must be the very first instruction of the declared constructor and you can only use one.

this keyword use to call constructor in the same class (other overloaded constructor)
syntax: this (args list); //compatible with args list in other constructor in the same class
super keyword use to call constructor in the super class.
syntax: super (args list); //compatible with args list in the constructor of the super class.
Ex:
public class Rect {
int x1, y1, x2, y2;
public Rect(int x1, int y1, int x2, int y2) // 1st constructor
{ ....//code to build a rectangle }
}
public Rect () { // 2nd constructor
this (0,0,width,height) // call 1st constructor (because it has **4 int args**), this is another way to build a rectangle
}
public class DrawableRect extends Rect {
public DrawableRect (int a1, int b1, int a2, int b2) {
super (a1,b1,a2,b2) // call super class constructor (Rect class)
}
}

using constructor from the super class

Java does not allow multiple inheritance, meaning that a class cannot inherit from two classes, which does not have anything in common, meaning that they are not on the same inheritance path. However, a class can inherit from more classes, if these classes are super classes of the direct super class of the class. But the class inherits from these classes indirectly, meaning that it does not "see" anything from these upper super classes, right? I was confused when considering constructors (using super() in the constructor). For example, if we have the following classes:
public class A {
public A() {
....
}
}
public class B extends A {
public B() {
super();
....
}
}
public class C extends B {
public C() {
super();
....
}
}
the constructor of class C invokes first the constructor of class B using super(). When this happens, the constructor of B itself invokes first the constructor of A (with super()), but the constructor of C does not know anything about the constructor of A, right? I mean, the inheritance is only from the direct super class - the first (nearest) class from the inheritance hierarchy. This is my question - with super() we mean only the constructor of the direct super class, no matter how many other classes we have in the inheritance hierarchy.
And this does not apply only for constructors, but for any methods and instance variables..
Regards

You have to invoke some constructor in your immediate base class. This can be
public class A {
public A() {
....
}
public A(String foo) {
....
}
}
public class B extends A {
public B() {
super();
.. or ..
super("ThisIsAB")
}
}
public class C extends B {
public C() {
super();
....
}
}
So for constructors you cannot AVOID constructing your intermediate base classes, but you can choose which constructor to use. If there is only the no-args constructor it's all handled for you with an implicit call to super. With multiple constructors you have some more choices.
super can refer to any non-private variable or method in any base class. So methods and variables are not the same as constructors in this respect.

Even if you could avoid calling the intermediate ctor, you wouldn't want to, because that would mean you had uninitialized pieces of the intermediate classes that might be acessed by the bottom-most derived class. To horrible effects.
But I sense that you're trying to trick your way around Java to do multiple inheritance. That is a Bad Thing. Instead, you can do it Java-wise by using an interface
class B extends A implements C {
// ... implement C methods here
}
or by using aggregation
class B extends A {
private C c;
}

Constructors for all parents are called. In fact, deep down C knows about A because B extends A. For example, if the class A contained method foo(), then you could call foo() from C.
So from your example, C calls the constructor from B, which calls the constructor from A. Additionnally, A also extends from the class Object. So the constructor in the class Object is also called!
Furthermore, you do not need to add a call to super(). If there is no call for the constructor of the parent, super is call implicitly.

As you say, C's constructor invokes B's constructor which invokes A's constructor. You can call any "A" methods on a C object, and a C object can see non-private fields in A.
Even if you override A's method "foo" in C, you can get the A version with "super.foo()", assuming B doesn't also override it.

As far as C knows, anything that it does not overwritten in C is contained in B, even if under the covers class A is where the implementation might be.
public class A {
public A() {
}
public void aMethod() {
}
}
public class B extends A {
public B() {
super();
}
}
public class C extends B {
public C() {
super();
}
public void doWork() {
super.aMethod();
}
}
So in this case A handles the implementation of aMethod(), even though calling super() in C's constructor called B's constructor directly, not A's.