Develop Reference

What happens to variables/objects in inner classes of function objects?

I have a function multi2 which returns inner class Inner as an Object.
What happens to a - where is it saved and how can I access it?
public class C {
private static Object multi2(final int a) {
class Inner {
public int hashCode() {
return 2*a;
}
}
return new Inner(); // What happens to a?
// Who allocates a?
// Can I Access a?
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
Object o = multi2(6);
System.out.println("o.hashCode() = " + o.hashCode());
o = multi2(4);
System.out.println("o.hashCode() = " + o.hashCode());
}
}

What happens at the implementation level is that a copy of the value of a is saved in a synthetic instance variable declared in the compiled version of the C.Inner class.
The value of a is passed to the compiled Inner constructor via an extra parameter.
The C.Inner.hashCode method uses the value of the synthetic variable. Accessing a in the source code of Inner.hashCode is transformed into accessing the corresponding synthetic variable in the compiled code.
The variable in the outer scope must be final1. The synthetic variable must be final2 in the Inner class. This maintains the illusion that (potentially) multiple instances of the Inner class are seeing the same a variable. (They aren't, but since the variable(s) can't be changed, it is not possible for the code of the inner class to tell the difference.)
If you use javap to look at the bytecodes for the compiled example, you will see the mechanisms used to implement this in the outer and the inner classes.
1 - or effectively final from Java 8 onwards.
2 - If a could be mutated by an Inner method, then two Inner instances with the same outer class need to share a mutable variable whose lifetime is (now) longer than the stackframe for a multi2 call. That entails somehow turning a from stack variable into something that lives on the heap. It would be expensive and complicated.

You have defined the class Inner inside the function so the scope of the class will be
restricted with in the method. And your function is static so it will be live as long as the class definition is loaded. You have override the hashCode function inside the InnerClass so every time you are calling the multi2(param) you are creating the hashCode for the instance of InnerClass and returning the instance of the InnerClass.
So as for you questions, please correct me if i am wrong.
What happens to a ?
a is with in the scope of your static method, so it will be live as long as the class definition is loaded.
Who allocates a?
scope of a is restricted inside the static method and static method does not require instance to access it but as for the static method/variable allocation, i think it depends on JVM.
Can I Access a?
No you cannot access a from outside you static method, it is restricted with in your static method.

Since the "a" is a local parameter, you could use a different approach to read the "a" value:
public class C {
public static Object multi2(final int a) {
return new Inner(a);
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
Object o = multi2(6);
System.out.println("o.hashCode() = " + o.hashCode());
System.out.println("o.getA() = " + ((Inner) o).getA());
o = multi2(4);
System.out.println("o.hashCode() = " + o.hashCode());
System.out.println("o.getA() = " + ((Inner) o).getA());
}
}
class Inner{
public int valueA;
public Inner(int a)
{
valueA = a;
}
public int getA() {
return valueA;
}
public int hashCode() {
return 2*valueA;
}
}

I wanted to know what was actually happening, so I compiled your code and looked at the bytecode output.
Basically what happens is the compiler adds in a constructor to your class 'Inner'. It also adds a single parameter to that constructor which takes 'a'. If your multi2() method was NOT static then there would probably also be a parameter to take 'this' where 'this' is the instance of 'C' that multi2() is executing on. BUT since we're in static context, there is no 'this'.
The compiler adds a private final field to your class 'Inner' and sets that private field using the value passed via the constructor. The compiler also converts
new Inner()
into
new Inner(a)
Hashcode then accesses the private field containing the value for a.
If 'a' was an object instead of a primitive, then it would be the same way, but a reference would be passed through instead of an actual number value.
How do you access this variable? Well you access it with reflections, but there are many problems:
1) You don't know the name of the field made by the compiler, so you can only get the name by looking at the bytecode. Don't trust decompilers as they might change the name. You gotta look at the bytecode yourself to find out.
2) The compiler probably marks the field as final, which means even if you can get reflections to access the field for you, you won't be able to update it.
3) It is entirely up to the compiler to figure out field names. Field names could change between builds depending on the compiler and it's mood.

Inner is a so called local class. a is a parameter passed to the method multi2 and accessable within that scope. Outside of that method, you cannot access a.

Java static variables and local variables [duplicate]

This question already has answers here:
Why is it not possible to shadow a local variable in a loop?
(7 answers)
Closed 5 years ago.
I am new in Java and came across one OCJA-1.8 sample question where I am having some doubt. I need clarification on this behavior of JVM.
public class Test{
static int x=1;//**This is static class level variable**
public static void main(String[] args){
int[] nums={1,2,3,4,5};
for(int x:nums){ // Local variable declared for for-each loop.
System.out.println(x);
}
}
}
Why the JVM have not thrown the error as duplicate variable, For the variable which is declared inside for each loop 'int x'. As static variable has class level scope ?

The local variable hides the original static field somewhat, but it is not inaccessible:
Test.x
And for non-static fields:
this.x // not in this case
So it is allowed, and in effect one often sees:
public class Pt {
private final int x;
public Pt(int x) {
this.x = x;
}
}
Which prevents the need to introduce some convention (_x, mX).
What is not allowed:
void f() {
int x = 42;
if (true) {
int x = 13; // COMPILER ERROR
...
}
}
As this is bad style, causing confusion.

The inner variable declaration of x override the static one.
If you need to access the static variable you can access it with Test.x

The duplicate variable compilation error happens for two variables with the same name declared in the same scope : fields or method declaration scope.
In your example, each variable is declared in a distinct scope.
As a consequence, as you refer x in the method declaring x, by default it refers to the variable with the nearer scope available (the x local variable) that so shadows the other variable (the x field variable).
To reference the shadowed variable :
if it is a static field (your case), prefix it with the class name declaring it : Test.x
if it is an instance field, prefix it with the this keyword : this.x

When you have a local variable same as static variable, static variable of the class is shadowed by the local variable.

It doesn't throw an error because Java has the concept of shadowing. In essence, the variable with the lowest scope is used.
The static field is still accessible, you just need to fully qualify it:
for(int x:nums){
System.out.println(x); // Local x
System.out.println(Test.x); // static x
}
This can be confusing to a reader of your code and so should be avoided in most cases. If you find yourself with a field and local variable named identically, there's probably something up and you should re-evaluate how you've named your variables.
In your specific case, x is not a descriptive name and both variables would benefit from better, more descriptive names.
In certain cases, such as within a constructor or setter method, it's beneficial to have local variables and fields with the same names, and this is where shadowing is a useful feature.

In a Java class, I can see that a class object and variable can have same name. Which value will be printed if they have same scope?

public class Simple {
public float price;
public static void main (String[] args) {
Simple price = new Simple ();
price.price = 4;
System.out.println(price);
}
}
What should be the output and why ? The object value or 4.0 ?

They do not have the same scope (or thay would be the same variable). The variable with the narrowest scope that still encloses the usage is the one used.
public static class Simple {
public float price;
public static void main(String[] args) {
// Narrower scope than the instance variable.
Simple price = new Simple();
price.price = 4;
// Uses the narrower one (the Price, not the float).
System.out.println(price);
}
}
Output
com.oldcurmudgeon.test.Test$Simple#15db9742

What should be the output and why ? The object value or 4.0 ?
The object value ... because within the main method the local variable price will hide the instance variable price.
(In fact, the println method calls toString() on the object and prints the resulting string. But I guess you knew that.)
In a Java class, I can see that a class object and variable can have same name. Which value will be printed if they have same scope?
That doesn't make sense in the context of your example, because the local variable and the instance variable don't have the same scope.
(And what is more, even if the instance field price wasn't hidden, you still would not be able to print it with System.out.println(price); because you can't refer to an instance variable like that in a static method. You can't refer to this in a static method, either implicitly or explicitly.)

Because price is the reference variable declared in your main method scope unlike float price that is declared in the Simple class scope as instance variable.
If you add a System.out.println(price); in your Simple constructor for example it must print 4.0 because he looks for the variable reference declared there.

Assign a static variable before declaring

I'm learning Java and write the simple code below:
public class Test {
private int a = b;
private final static int b = 10;
public int getA() {
return a;
}
}
public class Hello {
public static void main(String[] args) {
Test test = new Test();
System.out.println(test.getA());
}
}
The result: 10. Well done! It run successfully and have no error.
Can anyone please explain why I can assign a static variable before declaring it?

The assignment
private int a = b;
takes place when you create a new instance of Test (just before the constructor is called).
The declaration and initialization of the static variable b, takes place before the instance is created, when the class is loaded.
The order of the statements doesn't matter, since static variables are always initialized first.

Javavariables are initialised this order:
Static variables of the superclasses if any
static variables of the current class.
Static variables, and static blocks in the order that they are
declared
Instance variables of the superclasses
All instance variables of the current class.
Instance variables, and instance level initialisation blocks, in
declaration order
Therefore "b" is intialized before the "a".
Hope this helps.

Static variables are bound to a class - which of course always exists before instances of the class. Thus, you can freely assign it to instance fields.

The order of declaring variables doesn't really matter in your code as in reality the static variable is going to be initialized before non-static ones.

The code you wrote works well because
private final static int b = 10;
is a class variable (static field). Those type of variables are initialised for first.
Then is executed the line
private int a = b;
which initialise the instance variable (field) a.
In short, it doesn't matter the order in which those variables are declared in your code. Class variables are always declared before instance variables.

Difference between Static and final?

I'm always confused between static and final keywords in java.
How are they different ?

The static keyword can be used in 4 scenarios
static variables
static methods
static blocks of code
static nested class
Let's look at static variables and static methods first.
Static variable
It is a variable which belongs to the class and not to object (instance).
Static variables are initialized only once, at the start of the execution. These variables will be initialized first, before the initialization of any instance variables.
A single copy to be shared by all instances of the class.
A static variable can be accessed directly by the class name and doesn’t need any object.
Syntax: Class.variable
Static method
It is a method which belongs to the class and not to the object (instance).
A static method can access only static data. It can not access non-static data (instance variables) unless it has/creates an instance of the class.
A static method can call only other static methods and can not call a non-static method from it unless it has/creates an instance of the class.
A static method can be accessed directly by the class name and doesn’t need any object.
Syntax: Class.methodName()
A static method cannot refer to this or super keywords in anyway.
Static class
Java also has "static nested classes". A static nested class is just one which doesn't implicitly have a reference to an instance of the outer class.
Static nested classes can have instance methods and static methods.
There's no such thing as a top-level static class in Java.
Side note:
main method is static since it must be be accessible for an application to run before any instantiation takes place.
final keyword is used in several different contexts to define an entity which cannot later be changed.
A final class cannot be subclassed. This is done for reasons of security and efficiency. Accordingly, many of the Java standard library classes are final, for example java.lang.System and java.lang.String. All methods in a final class are implicitly final.
A final method can't be overridden by subclasses. This is used to prevent unexpected behavior from a subclass altering a method that may be crucial to the function or consistency of the class.
A final variable can only be initialized once, either via an initializer or an assignment statement. It does not need to be initialized at the point of declaration: this is called a blank final variable. A blank final instance variable of a class must be definitely assigned at the end of every constructor of the class in which it is declared; similarly, a blank final static variable must be definitely assigned in a static initializer of the class in which it is declared; otherwise, a compile-time error occurs in both cases.
Note: If the variable is a reference, this means that the variable cannot be re-bound to reference another object. But the object that it references is still mutable, if it was originally mutable.
When an anonymous inner class is defined within the body of a method, all variables declared final in the scope of that method are accessible from within the inner class. Once it has been assigned, the value of the final variable cannot change.

static means it belongs to the class not an instance, this means that there is only one copy of that variable/method shared between all instances of a particular Class.
public class MyClass {
public static int myVariable = 0;
}
//Now in some other code creating two instances of MyClass
//and altering the variable will affect all instances
MyClass instance1 = new MyClass();
MyClass instance2 = new MyClass();
MyClass.myVariable = 5; //This change is reflected in both instances
final is entirely unrelated, it is a way of defining a once only initialization. You can either initialize when defining the variable or within the constructor, nowhere else.
note A note on final methods and final classes, this is a way of explicitly stating that the method or class can not be overridden / extended respectively.
Extra Reading
So on the topic of static, we were talking about the other uses it may have, it is sometimes used in static blocks. When using static variables it is sometimes necessary to set these variables up before using the class, but unfortunately you do not get a constructor. This is where the static keyword comes in.
public class MyClass {
public static List<String> cars = new ArrayList<String>();
static {
cars.add("Ferrari");
cars.add("Scoda");
}
}
public class TestClass {
public static void main(String args[]) {
System.out.println(MyClass.cars.get(0)); //This will print Ferrari
}
}
You must not get this confused with instance initializer blocks which are called before the constructor per instance.

The two really aren't similar. static fields are fields that do not belong to any particular instance of a class.
class C {
public static int n = 42;
}
Here, the static field n isn't associated with any particular instance of C but with the entire class in general (which is why C.n can be used to access it). Can you still use an instance of C to access n? Yes - but it isn't considered particularly good practice.
final on the other hand indicates that a particular variable cannot change after it is initialized.
class C {
public final int n = 42;
}
Here, n cannot be re-assigned because it is final. One other difference is that any variable can be declared final, while not every variable can be declared static.
Also, classes can be declared final which indicates that they cannot be extended:
final class C {}
class B extends C {} // error!
Similarly, methods can be declared final to indicate that they cannot be overriden by an extending class:
class C {
public final void foo() {}
}
class B extends C {
public void foo() {} // error!
}

static means there is only one copy of the variable in memory shared by all instances of the class.
The final keyword just means the value can't be changed. Without final, any object can change the value of the variable.

final -
1)When we apply "final" keyword to a variable,the value of that variable remains constant.
(or)
Once we declare a variable as final.the value of that variable cannot be changed.
2)It is useful when a variable value does not change during the life time of a program
static -
1)when we apply "static" keyword to a variable ,it means it belongs to class.
2)When we apply "static" keyword to a method,it means the method can be accessed without creating any instance of the class

Think of an object like a Speaker. If Speaker is a class, It will have different variables such as volume, treble, bass, color etc. You define all these fields while defining the Speaker class. For example, you declared the color field with a static modifier, that means you're telling the compiler that there is exactly one copy of this variable in existence, regardless of how many times the class has been instantiated.
Declaring
static final String color = "Black";
will make sure that whenever this class is instantiated, the value of color field will be "Black" unless it is not changed.
public class Speaker {
static String color = "Black";
}
public class Sample {
public static void main(String args[]) {
System.out.println(Speaker.color); //will provide output as "Black"
Speaker.color = "white";
System.out.println(Speaker.color); //will provide output as "White"
}}
Note : Now once you change the color of the speaker as final this code wont execute, because final keyword makes sure that the value of the field never changes.
public class Speaker {
static final String color = "Black";
}
public class Sample {
public static void main(String args[]) {
System.out.println(Speaker.color); //should provide output as "Black"
Speaker.color = "white"; //Error because the value of color is fixed.
System.out.println(Speaker.color); //Code won't execute.
}}
You may copy/paste this code directly into your emulator and try.

Easy Difference,
Final : means that the Value of the variable is Final and it will not change anywhere. If you say that final x = 5 it means x can not be changed its value is final for everyone.
Static : means that it has only one object. lets suppose you have x = 5, in memory there is x = 5 and its present inside a class. if you create an object or instance of the class which means there a specific box that represents that class and its variables and methods. and if you create an other object or instance of that class it means there are two boxes of that same class which has different x inside them in the memory. and if you call both x in different positions and change their value then their value will be different. box 1 has x which has x =5 and box 2 has x = 6. but if you make the x static it means it can not be created again.
you can create object of class but that object will not have different x in them.
if x is static then box 1 and box 2 both will have the same x which has the value of 5. Yes i can change the value of static any where as its not final. so if i say box 1 has x and i change its value to x =5 and after that i make another box which is box2 and i change the value of box2 x to x=6. then as X is static both boxes has the same x. and both boxes will give the value of box as 6 because box2 overwrites the value of 5 to 6.
Both final and static are totally different. Final which is final can not be changed. static which will remain as one but can be changed.
"This is an example. remember static variable are always called by their class name. because they are only one for all of the objects of that class. so
Class A has x =5, i can call and change it by A.x=6; "

Static and final have some big differences:
Static variables or classes will always be available from (pretty much) anywhere. Final is just a keyword that means a variable cannot be changed. So if had:
public class Test{
public final int first = 10;
public static int second = 20;
public Test(){
second = second + 1
first = first + 1;
}
}
The program would run until it tried to change the "first" integer, which would cause an error. Outside of this class, you would only have access to the "first" variable if you had instantiated the class. This is in contrast to "second", which is available all the time.

Static is something that any object in a class can call, that inherently belongs to an object type.
A variable can be final for an entire class, and that simply means it cannot be changed anymore. It can only be set once, and trying to set it again will result in an error being thrown. It is useful for a number of reasons, perhaps you want to declare a constant, that can't be changed.
Some example code:
class someClass
{
public static int count=0;
public final String mName;
someClass(String name)
{
mname=name;
count=count+1;
}
public static void main(String args[])
{
someClass obj1=new someClass("obj1");
System.out.println("count="+count+" name="+obj1.mName);
someClass obj2=new someClass("obj2");
System.out.println("count="+count+" name="+obj2.mName);
}
}
Wikipedia contains the complete list of java keywords.

I won't try to give a complete answer here. My recommendation would be to focus on understanding what each one of them does and then it should be cleare to see that their effects are completely different and why sometimes they are used together.
static is for members of a class (attributes and methods) and it has to be understood in contrast to instance (non static) members. I'd recommend reading "Understanding Instance and Class Members" in The Java Tutorials. I can also be used in static blocks but I would not worry about it for a start.
final has different meanings according if its applied to variables, methods, classes or some other cases. Here I like Wikipedia explanations better.

Static variable values can get changed although one copy of the variable traverse through the application, whereas Final Variable values can be initialized once and cannot be changed throughout the application.