I am building an app with a drawer layout similar to the Android Facebook app. I am wondering what the best method for architecture is. Should I have a main activity which is responsible for the action bar, and then have it use fragments to display the content of each menu item, or should I be using one activity to manage the action bar, and then have each menu item kick off entirely separate activities?
I could also imagine building multiple activities, which each have to manage the action bar. This option seems the worst.
You have two architecture options here
MainActivity with Fragments
ParentActivity that handles drawer and lots of Activities that extends this Activity.
I have tried both in different projects and found some things worth sharing.
For me The MainActivity that handles drawer and then using Fragments to fill the display is the best.
You will need to handle callbacks from specific Fragments in your MainActivity and redirect them to the specific Fragment they came from. This is mainly if you use Interfaces in objects lower in the Arcitecture chain since you sometimes need to pass down Activity to certain objects. This generates more code that are not as generic as one might want in top level architecture node.
If you are using a ParentActivity and extending it for each ChildActivity, you can write all specific code in the child, meaning that the toplevel ParentActivity will almost only have generic code.
If you are using the ParentActivity with ChildActivities and you are switching between Activities, you fill get the graphic when an Activity closes and the next opens every time a user switches between navigation objects. If you use Fragments this wont happen as the Fragment will be switched in the background. The user will also experience that the navigation drawer will be closed and recreated each time he clicks on an item there.
Its also unnessecary to recreate the navigation drawer with each click on an item. This is a minus for the ParentActivity approach.
With the ParentActivity approach you will also have to keep track of how the backbutton should function, this will be autoaticly handled for you with Fragments. Also when starting new Activities you have to choose if a new Activity should be created or if the old should be killed etc.
Just my 5c, hopes it helps :)
The best way is to use one Activity with one Fragment per section/view.
Take a look at the design documentation.
Also see the Tutorial and Sample Application. It's fairly straight-forward.
You will have one activity which manages ActionBar, Drawer (ListView!) and Fragment.
Every time it clicks an item in the ListView it updates the fragment with the new view.
If you use different Activities then you should use intents with a very bad effect, use a different activity only if needed (if it's totally unrelated to the current activity maybe?)
Official documentation: http://developer.android.com/training/implementing-navigation/nav-drawer.html
If you got any problem in creating this, online you can found more tutorials but the official is very great.
You should have the activity holding the actionbar & drawer
When using a drawer you should not start new activities from within the drawer but fragment instead
Good post & video about it: https://plus.google.com/u/0/+RomanNurik/posts/3nMVVQzUTjG
another good read: http://www.androiduipatterns.com/2013/05/the-new-navigation-drawer-pattern.html
And finally this is a must see also (check the slides or the video): https://plus.google.com/u/0/+NickButcher/posts/1jeyV2n1ZpM
Related
I am developing an activity that contains a kind of mix between a menu and a progress bar. Below this, there are views that are "visible" or "gone" depending on the progress in which the user is. I have programmed everything in the same activity, but I have doubts that this is efficient because we are talking about more than 1200 lines of code and most of it is only used in part of the progress.
Do you think creating a structure with fragments would be better? If so, how would you go about changing from one fragment to the next from a button within the fragment?
I am beginner to android..I am started new android project..for supporting
different screen size..in fragment documentation they given to use fragment..but
why cant i use activity in android..if i use activity or fragment..which i should i use in this both..please dont give link of activity or fragment..please anyone answer me..i dont know which to use?...i want about all documentation they given about activity and fragment but i dint understand which to use..below is the link i read about fragment..if i use activity i should do more codings?
https://developer.android.com/guide/components/fragments.html
In fact you can't use a Fragment alone, Fragments are inside the Activity.
One point of using the Fragments for supporting different screen sizes is the ability to implement some views like a "Master/Detail" view.
A Fragment, as its name says, is a part of a bigger controller "the Activity", its reference can be removed and it's cleaner than having a big massive Activity to handle all the states of a view.
So the use case is completely depends on your project and its User Interface. I'd be glad to help you if you give me more information about your project and its design.
I think you will need at least one activity. And then for better handling different device rotations and screen sizes you can use one or more fragments inside this activity.
I try to explain this with an example:
You want to create a nice music player app which should look nice in portrait and landscape mode.
You split your app up into three fragments:
Here you can see how the app looks in portrait mode. The activity shows two fragments: The first fragment only consists of a listview. There the song titles are listed. On the bottom you can see the second fragment, which displays the song title of the current playing song and got a button for pausing the music.
When your user uses the music player app on a tablet in landscape mode you have more space for displaying stuff. Then the activity shows the list fragment (which also gets displayed in portrait mode) and it shows a third fragment which shows detailed information about the current playing song (e.g. the album image) and a progress bar.
By using fragments you only need to write the code for the list once.
Sweet and Simple thing, What i recommend is always use Fragments,
But for Fragment you will require Activity.
Take it in this way , Activity is a Canvas on which you can put any number of Fragments.
Whatever your UI is always use Fragment present on a activity if you want to show one screen even then also, So that you will always have Flexibilty to use all those cool things which fragments provides,maybe in future or in current.
If you use activity it has limits,FOR EXAMPLE, LIKE in INSTAGRAM AT BOTTOM, It has FIVE OPTIONS, Suppose THOSE OPTIONS ARE ON A ACTIVITY AND BY CLICKING ON THEM YOU CAN SWITCH TO DIFFERENT FRAGMENTS.
For more info:
Here is the most accepted answer for this topic.
I am following the Google tutorial for building your first android application. I got to the point where I needed to implement the actionbar actions with the functions openSearch() and openSettings().
I implemented all of this in the MainActivity.java file.
My question is this:
In the example app you can type a message and then send it and it displays it in a second activity. In the second activity, the top action bar changes and does not display my Search icon or perform the action when the settings button is clicked. In order to have these icons displayed in the action bar for this activity as well, do I need to add those methods and update onOptionsItemSelected method in DisplayMessageActivity.java as well as in MainActivity.java? Is this the only way to carry the action bar icons/actions over? To retype the same methods in each activity that you want them in? Or is there a better way to do it?
My other somewhat related curiosity is this. The method openSettings() is called when I click the 3 vertical dots and then settings. These 3 vertical dots show up on every activity, and settings is always in the list. However clicking settings obviously doesn't perform the call to openSettings() when in the DisplayMessageActivity and not MainActivity. How is it that settings and the vertical dots are carried over?
Second to last, how can I add other selections to the drop down list from the options/vertical dots in the action bar? Settings is always there although it responds differently in each activity which was my first question. But I would like to add certain things to the options menu that are on all activities, and some things that are unique to some activities. I assume there must be a better way than repeating switch statements and methods in every Activity.java file.
And finally, what is the best practice to implement an action bar over multiple activities?
Obviously different activities will often have different icons/actions in the action bar, however some things like the 3 vertical dots(options) and settings within that would obviously be acceptable to have in every Activity, while it would be nice to add other things to the options list I don't see why settings should ever change across activities. Yet as I stated before the method is not called in DisplayMessageActivity unless I repeat the code in DisplayMessageActivity.java that I had added to MainActivity.java. I'm confused as to where I can add these so that they are displayed on all activities without repeating code. And I'm confused as to how the actionbar's options/vertical dots are carried over to all activities while others require the repeating of code in each activities' java file that I want them to show up in.
I know this was a bit of a long winded quesiton, I will clarify if necessary. I'm just a bit confused. I was able to make it through the tutorial fine as I have a decent understanding of java. However google's guide isn't written that well and the Android environment is very confusing to a beginner.
I do understand how things work to a degree, I just want to ensure that I'm actually doing it in a way that when my app grows in complexity it won't be a mess of unnecessarily repeated statements and methods.
Thanks in advance for any assistance and tips.
In order to have these icons displayed in the action bar for this activity as well, do I need to add those methods and update onOptionsItemSelected method in DisplayMessageActivity.java as well as in MainActivity.java? Is this the only way to carry the action bar icons/actions over? To retype the same methods in each activity that you want them in? Or is there a better way to do it?
That is certainly one solution, but as you obviously know, it's not a very good one. There are at least two alternative solutions:
Create a MenuActivity class which implements all the logic for common menu items and then extend this class from all of your activities, rather than extending the standard Activity class.
Use fragments to implement your UI. Fragments are similar to activities in that they create UI elements from an XML layout. One difference is that they live inside a "host activity". In this particular case, the host activity will provide the common menu functionality and each fragment can customize it further depending on your needs.
How is it that settings and the vertical dots are carried over?
Most likely your DisplayMessageActivity overrides onCreateOptionsMenu() and inflates a menu XML layout which was created by Android Studio (or Eclipse?) when you created the activity class.
I have a tabbed interface for my program - there are two tabs: take photo and view photos.
As the name suggests, the user can take a photo in "take photo" and the user can view photos taken in "view photos". Right now the way its set up I use one single MainActivity and I have TakePhotoFragment and ViewPhotoFragment -- question is: does this contradict the principles in which Fragments are supposed to be used in? I don't really anticipate having both fragments displayed in a single screen (e.g. on a tablet), but I don't see how I can use one activity for each because of the limitations of the tabbed interface (when I created the activity in eclipse, I was prompted to select what kind of layout, I chose tabbed layout, and automatically code for fragments within an activity corresponding to several tabs was generated)
Can anyone help? Should "take photo" and "view photos" be fragments or activities?
It should definitely be fragments.
This does in no way contradict anything, plus I do not understand your concern about showing both fragments in a single screen. If you do not want that to happen, you just program accordingly. That is certainly not something that just happens because of the choices that you have mentioned so far.
Fragments is the best method you can use for the purpose you mentioned above. You can check the below links to know about the usage of fragments.
Creating a fragment
Fragments
android fragments
android fragments tutorial
I have one fragment that deals with previewing and so taking pictures, and on that fragment I want to have an option in the action bar have an item.
On some of the other fragments I would like to have items that will be in common, but only if not on a large device (tablet), as the tablet will have a fragment that handles controlling activities.
So, since I only have one Activity in my application, what is the best way to have context sensitive menus in the actionbar, in a fragment.
And how do I best show items only if on a small device?
It appears the best approach is to just have the fragment add the items to the actionbar as described here:
http://developer.android.com/guide/components/fragments.html#ActionBar
But, it will also be necessary to look for an id that is unique to the non-large layout to decide if certain menu items should be included.