Develop Reference

Correct conditions for quickselect

I am implementing the quick-select algorithm to get the kth element in an array, and I am stuck at a place where I don't know how to resolve. Here is my code that doesn't work:
public static void main (String[] args) {
int[] arr = new int[]{7,6,5,4,3,2,1};
int k = 4;
quickSort(arr, 0, arr.length - 1, k);
return arr[k];
}
private static void quickSelect(int[] nums, int start, int end, int k) {
if (start < end) {
int partitionIndex = getPartitionIndex(nums, start, end);
if (partitionIndex == k) {
return;
}
quickSelect(nums, start, partitionIndex - 1, k);
quickSelect(nums, partitionIndex + 1, end, k);
}
}
private int getPartitionIndex(int[] nums, int start, int end) {
int pivot = nums[end];
int index = start;
for (int i = start; i <= end; i++) {
int current = nums[i];
if (current < pivot) {
swap(nums, index, i);
index++;
}
}
swap(nums, index, end);
return index;
}
private void swap(int[] nums, int i, int j) {
if (i == j) {
return;
}
nums[i] = nums[i] ^ nums[j];
nums[j] = nums[i] ^ nums[j];
nums[i] = nums[i] ^ nums[j];
}
Sure, if I remove these lines:
if (partitionIndex == k) {
return;
}
It becomes quicksort and works fine. And I understand why it's not working, it is since the array I am getting from 0 to k might not be sorted as I return at the above condition. But I am not able to find the right conditions where I sort only the first k elements in the array and leave out the rest, so that I don't do any extra work. I've looked at some implementations online and spent some time on the above, but not able to figure it out, so reaching out for help.

If k < partitionIndex, only check the left partition, else only check the right partition.
if (k < partitionIndex)
quickSelect(nums, start, partitionIndex - 1, k);
else
quickSelect(nums, partitionIndex + 1, end, k);

Merge sort auxiliary array creation/ middle question

I have some questions about my code. I've marked it with ---><--- down below.
public class Main {
public static void main(String[] args) {
int[] arr = {5, 4, 3, 2, 1, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 10};
int[] aux = new int[arr.length];
sort(arr, aux, 0, arr.length - 1);
for (int i = 0; i < arr.length; i++) {
System.out.print(arr[i] + " ");
}
}
public static void sort(int[] arr, int[] aux, int low, int high) {
// what does these lines do? --->
if (low >= high) {
return;
}
int mid = low + (high - low) / 2; // why cant it just be high - low / 2
//<--- These lines
sort(arr, aux, low, mid); //sorts left side
sort(arr, aux, mid + 1, high); //sorts right side
merge(arr, aux, low, mid, high); //merges the two sides
}
public static void merge(int[] arr, int[] aux, int low, int mid, int high) {
for (int k = low; k <= high; k++) {
aux[k] = arr[k];
}
//copies the array into an aux array
int i = low; //counter for the left side
int j = mid + 1; //counter for the right side
for (int k = low; k <= high; k++) {
if (i > mid) { //if i > mid meaning that if the left side of the array is empty then use the right side
arr[k] = aux[j++];
}
else if (j > high) { //if j > high then right side of array has been used so use left
arr[k] = aux[i++];
}
else if (aux[i] <= aux[j]) { //if value of left side is <= value of right then bring leftside value up to original array
arr[k] = aux[i++];
}
else { //value of right side is <= value of left so bring rightside value up to original array
arr[k] = aux[j++];
}
}
}
}
This is a part of the merge from GeeksForGeeks
void merge(int arr[], int l, int m, int r) {
/* Create temp arrays */
// These lines --->
int L[] = new int [n1];
int R[] = new int [n2];
//<---
}
With G4Geek's temp arrays:
Is it getting created every single time merge is called?
Does the memory just stay there?
Is the current code that I have better practice?
Thanks.

Quick sort imlpementation in Java-wrong output

I am trying to implement quick sort using Java.The partition function does what it should do.That is,partition the array around the pivot(I've chosen the element as the pivot). But the final output is not in sorted order.I cannot figure the error out.Can someone help?
public class Quick_sort {
public static int arr[] = {11, 2, 7, 1, 5, 4, 12, 65, 23};
public static int temp = 0;
public static void main(String args[]) {
int p=0;
int r=arr.length;
quick_sort(p,r);
for(int i: arr)
System.out.println(i);
}
public static int partition(int p, int r) {
if(p < r) {
int pivot=arr[p];
int i=1;
for(int j=1;j<r;j++) {
if(arr[j]<pivot) {
temp=arr[j];
arr[j]=arr[i];
arr[i]=temp;
i++;
}
}
temp=arr[i-1];
arr[i-1]=arr[p];
arr[p]=temp;
for(int m=0;m<r;m++) {
if(arr[m]==pivot) {
temp=m;
}
}
}
return temp;
}
public static void quick_sort(int p,int r) {
if(p>=r) return;
int index=partition(p,r);
quick_sort(p,index-1);
quick_sort(index+1,r-1);
}
}

In your last line
quick_sort(index+1,r-1);
You skip the last element of the array. But the last element should be sorted as well. Try it with:
quick_sort(index+1,r);
And it is better to adapt the variables i and j in the partition method to the current processed part of the array.

So I tried to fix it. Try it with (main function):
int r=arr.length-1;
and change the partition function to:
public static int partition(int p, int r) {
if(p < r) {
int pivot=arr[p];
int i= p ;
for(int j=(p+1);j<=r;j++) {
if(arr[j]<pivot) {
temp=arr[j];
arr[j]=arr[i + 1];
arr[i + 1] = arr[i];
arr[i] = temp;
i++;
}
}
temp = i;
}
return temp;
}
as well as the in the quick-sort method:
quick_sort(p,index-1);
quick_sort(index+1,r);
Do you see your problem? Your main problem was to not adapt the variables to the smaller parts you are actually looking at at the moment. It did well for the first partition round, but not for the following, as you had the former variables.

This is a complete example of a QuickSort implementation :
public class QuickSort {
public static void main(String[] args) {
int[] x = { 9, 2, 4, 7, 3, 7, 10 };
System.out.println(Arrays.toString(x));
int low = 0;
int high = x.length - 1;
quickSort(x, low, high);
System.out.println(Arrays.toString(x));
}
public static void quickSort(int[] arr, int low, int high) {
if (arr == null || arr.length == 0)
return;
if (low >= high)
return;
// pick the pivot
int middle = low + (high - low) / 2;
int pivot = arr[middle];
// make left < pivot and right > pivot
int i = low, j = high;
while (i <= j) {
while (arr[i] < pivot) {
i++;
}
while (arr[j] > pivot) {
j--;
}
if (i <= j) {
int temp = arr[i];
arr[i] = arr[j];
arr[j] = temp;
i++;
j--;
}
}
// recursively sort two sub parts
if (low < j)
quickSort(arr, low, j);
if (high > i)
quickSort(arr, i, high);
}
}
you can find more here.

Find Kth min elem by randomized pivot method. Some weird bug

I try to use "randomized pivot" method to find the Kth min elem among given array.
[The code]
public class FindKthMin {
// Find the Kth min elem by randomized pivot.
private static void exchange (int[] givenArray, int firstIndex, int secondIndex) {
int tempElem = givenArray[firstIndex];
givenArray[firstIndex] = givenArray[secondIndex];
givenArray[secondIndex] = tempElem;
}
private static int partition (int[] givenArray, int start, int end, int pivotIndex) {
// Debug:
//System.out.println("debug: start = " + start);
//System.out.println(">> end = " + end);
//System.out.println(">> pivotIndex = " + pivotIndex);
int pivot = givenArray[pivotIndex];
int left = start - 1;
int right = end;
boolean hasDone = false;
while (!hasDone) {
while (!hasDone) {
left ++;
if (left == right) {
hasDone = true;
break;
}
if (givenArray[left] >= pivot) {
// Exchange givenArray[left] and the givenArray[right].
exchange(givenArray, left, right);
break;
}
}
while (!hasDone) {
right --;
if (left == right) {
hasDone = true;
break;
}
if (givenArray[right] < pivot) {
// Exchange the givenArray[right] and the givenArray[left].
exchange(givenArray, right, left);
break;
}
}
}
givenArray[right] = pivot;
// Debug:
//System.out.println(">> split = " + right);
//System.out.println();
return right;
}
private static int findKthMin_RanP_Helper (int[] givenArray, int start, int end, int k) {
if (start > end) return -1;
// Generate a random num in the range[start, end].
int rand = (int)(start + Math.random() * (end - start + 1));
// Using this random num as the pivot index to partition the array in the current scope.
int split = partition(givenArray, start, end, rand);
if (k == split + 1) return givenArray[split];
else if (k < split + 1) return findKthMin_RanP_Helper(givenArray, start, split - 1, k);
else return findKthMin_RanP_Helper(givenArray, split + 1, end, k);
}
public static int findKthMin_RanP (int[] givenArray, int k) {
int size = givenArray.length;
if (k < 1 || k > size) return -1;
return findKthMin_RanP_Helper(givenArray, 0, size - 1, k);
}
// Main method to test.
public static void main (String[] args) {
// Test data: {8, 9, 5, 2, 8, 4}.
int[] givenArray = {8, 9, 5, 2, 8, 4};
// Test finding the Kth min elem by randomized pivot method.
System.out.println("Test finding the Kth min elem by randomized pivot method, rest = " + findKthMin_RanP(givenArray, 1));
}
}
But the result is unstable, sometimes right and sometimes wrong.
Please have a look at the 5th row of findKthMin_RanP_Helper method:
If I change this int split = partition(givenArray, start, end, rand); to int split = partition(givenArray, start, end, end);, the result is always correct. I really can not find what's wrong with this.
EDIT:
The problem comes from the "partition", the new partition should like this:
private static int partition_second_version (int[] givenArray, int start, int end, int pivotIndex) {
int pivot = givenArray[pivotIndex];
int left = start;
int right = end;
while (left <= right) {
while (givenArray[left] < pivot) left ++;
while (givenArray[right] > pivot) right --;
if (left <= right) {
// Exchange givenArray[left] and givenArray[right].
exchange(givenArray, left, right);
left ++;
right --;
}
}
return left;
}
And the findKthMin_RanP_Helper should be changed like this:
private static int findKthMin_RanP_Helper (int[] givenArray, int start, int end, int k) {
if (start > end) return -1;
// Generate a random num in the range[start, end].
int rand = start + (int)(Math.random() * ((end - start) + 1));
// Using this random num as the pivot index to partition the array in the current scope.
int split = partition_second_version (givenArray, start, end, rand);
if (k == split) return givenArray[split - 1];
else if (k < split) return findKthMin_RanP_Helper(givenArray, start, split - 1, k);
else return findKthMin_RanP_Helper(givenArray, split, end, k);
}

Your partition routine could be simplified...
private static int partition(int[] givenArray, int start, int end, int pivotIndex) {
final int pivot = givenArray[pivotIndex];
int left = start;
int right = end;
while (left < right) {
while (left < givenArray.length && givenArray[left] <= pivot) {
left++;
}
while (right > -1 && givenArray[right] > pivot) {
right--;
}
if (left >= right) {
break;
}
exchange(givenArray, right, left);
}
return right;
}
The one bug I see in your code is your partition routine. In the first exchange call, it is not guaranteed that the right index will always point to a value which is < pivot.

Merge Sort Java

I am trying to make a merge sort method, but it keeps on giving the wrong sorts. Where do I have change to make it actually sort the array? What part of the code has to be different? Thank you for your time.
public static void mergeSort(int[] array, int left, int lHigh, int right, int rHigh) {
int elements = (rHigh - lHigh +1) ;
int[] temp = new int[elements];
int num = left;
while ((left <= lHigh) && (right <= rHigh)){
if (a[left] <= array[right]) {
temp[num] = array[left];
left++;
}
else {
temp[num] = array[right];
right++;
}
num++;
}
while (left <= right){
temp[num] = array[left]; // I'm getting an exception here, and is it because of the num???
left += 1;
num += 1;
}
while (right <= rHigh) {
temp[num] = array[right];
right += 1;
num += 1;
}
for (int i=0; i < elements; i++){
array[rHigh] = temp[rHigh];
rHigh -= 1;
}
EDIT: now the mergeSort doesn't really sort the numbers, can someone tell me where it specifically is? especially when I print the "Testing merge sort" part.

First of all, I'm assuming this is academic rather than practical, since you're not using a built in sort function. That being said, here's some help to get you moving in the right direction:
Usually, one can think of a merge sort as two different methods: a merge() function that merges two sorted lists into one sorted list, and mergeSort() which recursively breaks the list into single element lists. Since a single element list is sorted already, you then merge all the lists together into one big sorted list.
Here's some off-hand pseudo-code:
merge(A, B):
C = empty list
While A and B are not empty:
If the first element of A is smaller than the first element of B:
Remove first element of A.
Add it to the end of C.
Otherwise:
Remove first element of B.
Add it to the end of C.
If A or B still contains elements, add them to the end of C.
mergeSort(A):
if length of A is 1:
return A
Split A into two lists, L and R.
Q = merge(mergeSort(L), mergeSort(R))
return Q
Maybe that'll help clear up where you want to go.
If not, there's always MergeSort at wikipedia.
Additional:
To help you out, here are some comments inline in your code.
public static void mergeSort(int[] array, int left, int lHigh, int right, int rHigh) {
// what do lHigh and rHigh represent?
int elements = (rHigh - lHigh +1) ;
int[] temp = new int[elements];
int num = left;
// what does this while loop do **conceptually**?
while ((left <= lHigh) && (right <= rHigh)){
if (a[left] <= a[right]) {
// where is 'pos' declared or defined?
temp[pos] = a[left];
// where is leftLow declared or defined? Did you mean 'left' instead?
leftLow ++;
}
else {
temp[num] = a[right];
right ++;
}
num++;
}
// what does this while loop do **conceptually**?
while (left <= right){
// At this point, what is the value of 'num'?
temp[num] = a[left];
left += 1;
num += 1;
}
while (right <= rHigh) {
temp[num] = a[right];
right += 1;
num += 1;
}
// Maybe you meant a[i] = temp[i]?
for (int i=0; i < elements; i++){
// what happens if rHigh is less than elements at this point? Could
// rHigh ever become negative? This would be a runtime error if it did
a[rHigh] = temp[rHigh];
rHigh -= 1;
}
I'm purposefully being vague so you think about the algorithm. Try inserting your own comments into the code. If you can write what is conceptually happening, then you may not need Stack Overflow :)
My thoughts here are that you are not implementing this correctly. This is because it looks like you're only touching the elements of the array only once (or close to only once). This means you have a worst case scenario of O(N) Sorting generally takes at least O(N * log N) and from what I know, the simpler versions of merge sort are actually O(N^2).
More:
In the most simplistic implementation of merge sort, I would expect to see some sort of recursion in the mergeSort() method. This is because merge sort is generally defined recursively. There are ways to do this iteratively using for and while loops, but I definitely don't recommend it as a learning tool until you get it recursively.
Honestly, I suggest taking either my pseudo-code or the pseudo-code you may find in a wikipedia article to implement this and start over with your code. If you do that and it doesn't work correctly still, post it here and we'll help you work out the kinks.
Cheers!
And finally:
// Precondition: array[left..lHigh] is sorted and array[right...rHigh] is sorted.
// Postcondition: array[left..rHigh] contains the same elements of the above parts, sorted.
public static void mergeSort(int[] array, int left, int lHigh, int right, int rHigh) {
// temp[] needs to be as large as the number of elements you're sorting (not half!)
//int elements = (rHigh - lHigh +1) ;
int elements = rHigh - left;
int[] temp = new int[elements];
// this is your index into the temp array
int num = left;
// now you need to create indices into your two lists
int iL = left;
int iR = right;
// Pseudo code... when you code this, make use of iR, iL, and num!
while( temp is not full ) {
if( left side is all used up ) {
copy rest of right side in.
make sure that at the end of this temp is full so the
while loop quits.
}
else if ( right side is all used up) {
copy rest of left side in.
make sure that at the end of this temp is full so the
while loop quits.
}
else if (array[iL] < array[iR]) { ... }
else if (array[iL] >= array[iR]) { ... }
}
}

public class MergeSort {
public static void main(String[] args) {
int[] arr = {5, 4, 7, 2, 3, 1, 6, 2};
print(arr);
new MergeSort().sort(arr, 0, arr.length - 1);
}
private void sort(int[] arr, int lo, int hi) {
if (lo < hi) {
int mid = (lo + hi) / 2;
sort(arr, lo, mid); // recursive call to divide the sub-list
sort(arr, mid + 1, hi); // recursive call to divide the sub-list
merge(arr, lo, mid, hi); // merge the sorted sub-lists.
print(arr);
}
}
private void merge(int[] arr, int lo, int mid, int hi) {
// allocate enough space so that the extra 'sentinel' value
// can be added. Each of the 'left' and 'right' sub-lists are pre-sorted.
// This function only merges them into a sorted list.
int[] left = new int[(mid - lo) + 2];
int[] right = new int[hi - mid + 1];
// create the left and right sub-list for merging into original list.
System.arraycopy(arr, lo, left, 0, left.length - 1);
System.arraycopy(arr, mid + 1, right, 0, left.length - 1);
// giving a sentinal value to marking the end of the sub-list.
// Note: The list to be sorted is assumed to contain numbers less than 100.
left[left.length - 1] = 100;
right[right.length - 1] = 100;
int i = 0;
int j = 0;
// loop to merge the sorted sequence from the 2 sub-lists(left and right)
// into the main list.
for (; lo <= hi; lo++) {
if (left[i] <= right[j]) {
arr[lo] = left[i];
i++;
} else {
arr[lo] = right[j];
j++;
}
}
}
// print the array to console.
private static void print(int[] arr) {
System.out.println();
for (int i : arr) {
System.out.print(i + ", ");
}
}
}

Here's another!
private static int[] mergeSort(int[] input){
if (input.length == 1)
return input;
int length = input.length/2;
int[] left = new int[length];
int[] right = new int[input.length - length];
for (int i = 0; i < length; i++)
left[i] = input[i];
for (int i = length; i < input.length; i++)
right[i-length] = input[i];
return merge(mergeSort(left),mergeSort(right));
}
private static int[] merge(int[] left, int[] right){
int[] merged = new int[left.length+right.length];
int lengthLeft = left.length;
int lengthRight = right.length;
while (lengthLeft > 0 && lengthRight > 0){
if (left[left.length - lengthLeft] < right[right.length - lengthRight]){
merged[merged.length -lengthLeft-lengthRight] = left[left.length - lengthLeft];
lengthLeft--;
}else{
merged[merged.length - lengthLeft-lengthRight] = right[right.length - lengthRight];
lengthRight--;
}
}
while (lengthLeft > 0){
merged[merged.length - lengthLeft] = left[left.length-lengthLeft];
lengthLeft--;
}
while (lengthRight > 0){
merged[merged.length - lengthRight] = right[right.length-lengthRight];
lengthRight--;
}
return merged;
}

static void mergeSort(int arr[],int p, int r) {
if(p<r) {
System.out.println("Pass "+k++);
int q = (p+r)/2;
mergeSort(arr,p,q);
mergeSort(arr,q+1,r);
//System.out.println(p+" "+q+" "+r);
merge(arr,p,q,r);
}
}
static void merge(int arr[],int p,int q,int r) {
int temp1[],temp2[];
//lower limit array
temp1 = new int[q-p+1];
//upper limit array
temp2 = new int[r-q];
for(int i=0 ; i< (q-p+1); i++){
temp1[i] = arr[p+i];
}
for(int j=0; j< (r-q); j++){
temp2[j] = arr[q+j+1];
}
int i = 0,j=0;
for(int k=p;k<=r;k++){
// This logic eliminates the so called sentinel card logic mentioned in Coreman
if(i!= temp1.length
&& (j==temp2.length || temp1[i] < temp2[j])
) {
arr[k] = temp1[i];
// System.out.println(temp1[i]);
i++;
}
else {
//System.out.println(temp2[j]);
arr[k] = temp2[j];
j++;
}
}
}

>
Merge Sort Using Sentinel
This codes works perfectly fine.
public void mergeSort(int a[], int low, int high) {
if (low < high) {
int mid = (low + high) / 2;
mergeSort(a, low, mid);
mergeSort(a, mid + 1, high);
merge(a, low, mid, high);
}
}
public void merge(int a[], int low, int mid, int high) {
int n1 = mid - low + 1;// length of an array a1
int n2 = high - mid; // length of an array a2
int a1[] = new int[n1 + 1];
int a2[] = new int[n2 + 1];
int lowRange = low;
for (int i = 0; i < n1; i++) {
a1[i] = a[lowRange];
lowRange++;
}
for (int j = 0; j < n2; j++) {
a2[j] = a[mid + j + 1];
}
a1[n1] = Integer.MAX_VALUE; // inserting sentinel at the end of array a1
a2[n2] = Integer.MAX_VALUE; // inserting sentinel at the end of array a2
int i = 0;
int j = 0;
int k = low;
for (k = low; k <= high; k++) {
if (a1[i] >= a2[j]) {
a[k] = a2[j];
j++;
} else {
a[k] = a1[i];
i++;
}
}
if (a2.length >= a1.length) {
for (int ab = k; ab < a2.length; ab++) {
a[k] = a2[ab];
k++;
}
} else if (a1.length >= a2.length) {
for (int ab = k; ab < a1.length; ab++) {
a[k] = a1[ab];
k++;
}
}
}

Here's another alternative:
public class MergeSort {
public static void merge(int[]a,int[] aux, int f, int m, int l) {
for (int k = f; k <= l; k++) {
aux[k] = a[k];
}
int i = f, j = m+1;
for (int k = f; k <= l; k++) {
if(i>m) a[k]=aux[j++];
else if (j>l) a[k]=aux[i++];
else if(aux[j] > aux[i]) a[k]=aux[j++];
else a[k]=aux[i++];
}
}
public static void sort(int[]a,int[] aux, int f, int l) {
if (l<=f) return;
int m = f + (l-f)/2;
sort(a, aux, f, m);
sort(a, aux, m+1, l);
merge(a, aux, f, m, l);
}
public static int[] sort(int[]a) {
int[] aux = new int[a.length];
sort(a, aux, 0, a.length-1);
return a;
}
}

Here is a simple merge sort algorithm in Java:
Good Tip: Always use int middle = low + (high-low)/2 instead of int middle = (low + high)/2.
public static int[] mergesort(int[] arr) {
int lowindex = 0;
int highindex = arr.length-1;
mergesort(arr, lowindex, highindex);
return arr;
}
private static void mergesort(int[] arr, int low, int high) {
if (low == high) {
return;
} else {
int midIndex = low + (high-low)/2;
mergesort(arr, low, midIndex);
mergesort(arr, midIndex + 1, high);
merge(arr, low, midIndex, high);
}
}
private static void merge(int[] arr, int low, int mid, int high) {
int[] left = new int[mid-low+2];
for (int i = low; i <= mid; i++) {
left[i-low] = arr[i];
}
left[mid-low+1] = Integer.MAX_VALUE;
int[] right = new int[high-mid+1];
for (int i = mid+1; i <= high; i++) {
right[i-mid-1] = arr[i];
}
right[high - mid] = Integer.MAX_VALUE;
int i = 0;
int j = 0;
for (int k = low; k <= high; k++) {
if (left[i] <= right[j]) {
arr[k] = left[i];
i++;
} else {
arr[k] = right[j];
j++;
}
}
}

package com.sortalgo;
import java.util.Arrays;
public class MyMSort {
private static void merge(int[] array, int[] result, int low, int mid, int high) {
int k =low, i=low; int j=mid+1;
while(i<=mid && j<=high) {
if(array[i]<= array[j]) {
result[k++]=array[i++];
}else {
result[k++]=array[j++];
}
}
while(i<=mid) {
result[k++]=array[i++];
}
while(j<=high) {
result[k++]=array[j++];
}
for(i=low;i<=high;i++) {
array[i]=result[i];
}
}
private static void mergeSort(int[] array, int[] result, int low, int high) {
if(high == low) {
return ;
}
int mid = (low + high)/2;
mergeSort(array,result, low, mid );
mergeSort(array,result, mid+1, high );
merge(array, result, low, mid, high);
}
public static void main(String[] args) {
int[] array = {8,4,3,12,25,6,13,10};
int[] result = new int[array.length];
mergeSort(array, result, 0, array.length-1 );
for(int i=0; i<=array.length-1;i++) {
System.out.println(array[i]);
}
}
}