In my Spring project, I have an entity Customer.
Now once we get a new Customer, we persist it in our system, and exactly after one hour, I want to check if the Customer has made any purchase.
If yes, I take some action. If no, the some other.
I contemplated two strategies,
1) Firing up an event when the Customer is persisted. And then having the event listener thread sleep for one hour. I believe this will be a very bad way to handle this.
2) Having a cron check every once in a while for customers for whom one hour has passed since registration. But then, I figure it will be very difficult to be accurate. I would have to run the cron every minute which won't be great.
Any ideas?
You could use the 'ScheduledThreadPoolExecutor' which as per javadoc is:
A ThreadPoolExecutor that can additionally schedule commands to run after a given delay, or to execute periodically
In your case, when a customer is created, you can use the 'schedule' method to wake up after 1 hour and then perform required activities. This method can also be used if you want those activities to be executed periodically as well.
I believe run the cron every minute is not that bad, how many customers would you handle in one minute?
Although not sure why you cannot use the event when a registered Customer will make any purchase i.e. when a particular registered customer will make purchase you can take the action inline as and then.
You described 2 strategies both will work but I would prefer to run cron job which you can configure explicitly. In that way you avoid the overhead of maintaining the threads. If you configure the cron job timing correctly and allow a single job to run at a time I do not see any problem with that. Remember cron jobs are used for batch processing rather than handling events.
Related
I am developing spring mvc application.
I have gone through below links
http://docs.spring.io/spring/docs/current/spring-framework-reference/html/scheduling.html#scheduling-annotation-support-scheduled
http://www.mkyong.com/spring-batch/spring-batch-and-spring-taskscheduler-example/
These guide for how to schedule.
But I have to give it to the users, to schedule(run on daily/weekly basis etc.) some functionality from GUI.
Can any one please help me how can I achieve this?
Suppose you have several tasks to be scheduled by user.
Define a Enum for the tasks names and a Runner to run task by enum. Define a job to be executed every second (minute, hour). The job just checks whether there is a user's task to be executed.
Now user defines such a task whith following params
TaskType (the Enum value)
TaskTime (when it should be started e.g. 12:00)
TaskPeriod (how often it should be called)
TaskTime and TaskPeriod could be joined e.g. in cron expression.
Then all the task info is stored somewhere (e.g. in DB).
Your permanent Job every second reads from the DB whether there is a task to be executed. It checks task time and task period and compares with current time. If it's time to start it gets enum value and calls Runner's method for the enum.
Please check the link. It explains how to schedule tasks by giving crone expressions in a property file.
Other solution is using the quartz library directly. We can schedule or reschedule jobs easily using that. Refer this.
Hope this will help.
I'm making use of Quartz Scheduling and there are 2 jobs. First Job is performing the tasks for around 2 minutes and the Second one is to be setup for Cleaning Operations of Temporary Files. So, I need to setup the Schedule to work in a way that after the first job is executed/finished performing tasks I need to do the cleaning operations with the help of Second Job.
Considering the Example 9 - Job Listeners under Quartz 2.1.x which states that we can define a method named jobWasExecuted( _, _ ); in the Job Listener and it executes when the 1st job is executed/or comes in running state.
Are we able to setup the schedule which can listen for the first job finishing then executes second? or,
Are we able to define the join() method like in Java Multithreading which can execute on the completion of first job?
There currently is no "direct" or "free" way to chain triggers with
Quartz. However there are several ways you can accomplish it without
much effort. Below is an outline of a couple approaches:
One way is to use a listener (i.e. a TriggerListener, JobListener or
SchedulerListener) that can notice the completion of a job/trigger and
then immediately schedule a new trigger to fire. This approach can get
a bit involved, since you'll have to inform the listener which job
follows which - and you may need to worry about persistence of this
information.
Another way is to build a Job that contains within its JobDataMap the name of the next job to fire, and as the job completes (the last step in its Execute() method) have the job schedule the next job. Several people are doing this and have had good luck. Most have made a base (abstract) class that is a Job that knows how to get the job name and group out of the JobDataMap using special keys (constants) and contains code to schedule the identified job. Then
they simply make extensions of this class that included the additional
work the job should do.
Ref: http://www.quartz-scheduler.net/documentation/faq.html#how-do-i-chain-job-execution?-or,-how-do-i-create-a-workflow?
I know this is an old question, but nevertheless there are 2 more options available to chain the execution of your jobs which people can find useful:
1) Use the JobChainingJobListener that is included in the standard Quartz distribution since very early releases. This listener allows you to programmatically define simple job chains using its addJobChainLink method.
2) Use a commercial solution such as QuartzDesk that I am the principal developer of. QuartzDesk contains a robust job chaining engine that allows you to externalize the definition of your job chains from the application code and enables you to update your job chains at runtime through a GUI without modifying, redeploying and restarting your application. A job chain can be associated with a particular job, trigger or it can be a global job chain that is executed whenever any of your jobs execute (useful for global job execution failure handlers etc.).
From http://www.quartz-scheduler.net/documentation/faq.html#how-do-i-chain-job-execution?-or,-how-do-i-create-a-workflow
How do I keep a Job from firing concurrently?
Quartz.NET 2.x
Implement IJob and also decorate your job class with
[DisallowConcurrentExecution] attribute. Read the API documentation
for DisallowConcurrentExecutionAttribute for more information.
The annotation is available in the Java implementation.
I have an requirement where I have to send the alerts when the record in db is not updated/changed for specified intervals. For example, if the received purchase order doesn't processed within one hour, the reminder should be sent to the delivery manager.
The reminder/alert should sent exactly at the interval (including seconds). If the last modified time is 13:55:45 means, the alert should be triggered 14:55:45. There could be million rows needs to be tracked.
The simple approach could be implementing a custom scheduler and all the records will registered with it. But should poll the database to look for the change every second and it will lead to performance problem.
UPDATE:
Another basic approach would be a creating a thread for each record and put it on sleep for 1 hour (or) Use some queuing concept which has timeout. But still it has performance problems
Any thoughts on better approach to implement the same?
probably using internal JMS queue would be better solution - for example you may want to use scheduled message feature http://docs.jboss.org/hornetq/2.2.2.Final/user-manual/en/html/examples.html#examples.scheduled-message with hornetq.
You can ask broker to publish alert message after exactly 1h. From the other hand during processing of some trading activity you can manually delete this message meaning that the trade activity has been processed without errors.
Use Timer for each reminder.i.e. If the last modified time is 17:49:45 means, the alert should be triggered 18:49:45 simply you should create a dynamic timer scheduling for each task it'll call exact after one hour.
It is not possible in Java, if you really insist on the "Real-timeness". In Java you may encouter Garbage collector's stop-the-world phase and you can never guarantee the exact time.
If the approximate time is also permissible, than use some kind of scheduled queue as proposed in other answers, if not, than use real-time Java or some native call.
If we can assume that the orders are entered with increasing time then:
You can use a Queue with elements that have the properties time-of-order and order-id.
Each new entry that is added to the DB is also enqueued to this Queue.
You can check the element at the start of the Queue each minute.
When checking the element at the start of the Queue, if an hour has passed from the time-of-order, then search for the entry with order-id in the DB.
If found and was not updated then send a notification, else dequeue it from the Queue .
Quartz API provide a way in which i can create a Job and add it to scheduler for future use by doing something like
SchdularFactory.getSchedulerInstance().addJob(jobDetail, false);
This provides me the flexibility to create jobs store them with the scheduler and use them in later stage.
i am wondering is there any way i can create triggers and add them to scheduler to be used in future.
Not sure if this is valid requirement but if its not possible than all i have to do is to associate the Trigger with any given/existing Job
In Quartz there is a one-to-many relationship between jobs and triggers, which is understandable: one job can be run by several different triggers but one trigger can only run a single job. If you need to run several jobs, create one composite job that runs these jobs manually.
Back to your question. Creating a job without associated triggers is a valid use-case: you have a piece of logic and later you will attach one or more triggers to execute it at different points in time.
The opposite situation is weird - you want to create a trigger that will run something at a given time, but you don't know yet what. I can't imagine use-case for that.
Note that you can create a trigger for future use (with next fire time far in the future), but it must have a job attached.
Finally, check out How-To: Storing a Job for Later Use in the official documentation.
I'm about to create a small application which will be responsible for sending out various reports to various users at various intevals. We might be talking about 50 or 100 different reports going to different people. Some reports needs to be generated every day, some every week, and some every month.
I've been using the Quartz library earlier to run tasks at regular intervals. However, in order to keep things simple I like the thought of having a single Quartz thread taking care of all reports. That is, the thread should loop through all reports, say every 15 minutes, and determine wether it is time for one or more to be generated and sent. It does not matter if a report is generated at 12:00 or 12:15.
I'm thinking about wether it would be possible, somehow, for each report to set up specific times such as "mon#12:00,wed#12:00" or "fri#09:30". Then, based on that, the thread would determine if it was time to send a report or not.
My question is; has anyone else done something like this and does any libraries exist which can make it easy to implement this task?
why not simply register a separate quartz task instance for each report and let Quartz handle all the scheduling for you? That is after all the point behind it.
you can create just single thread and it would ping a "job schedule data structure" at some time interval to see if it needs to run a report. If yes, it would run the report, otherwise, it would go for a short nap and ping again after specified sleep time.
It will cause problem if one job takes too much time to complete and you start accumulating jobs.
The job schedule data structure would keep its record sorted by time stamp.