I have started a few days ago to learn about fault tolerance solutions in microservices. I have some microservices in my ecosystem and they are now interconnected with Eureka service lookup. I used FeignClient to call from one to another. As I heard and read, that Hystrix is getting into maintenance, I wondered if I could use Resilience4J in Feign instead of Hystrix. Well, at least not from annotation level right now as it seems. I found a great Feign.Builder adapter to add resilience4j fault tolerance features above a FeignClient as a decorator (https://github.com/resilience4j/resilience4j/tree/master/resilience4j-feign) so I wanted to use it.
So I used this, added together the features and added the default encoder, decoder, etc. items into the feign builder. Turns out I have to finish of course my code with a .target call which creates my client proxy and I could not really do this with Eureka in a good way:
The first constructor, which takes the class type and the URL is hardcoded, so if I add an eureka next server query into this parameter, it is just a hardcoded url for one of the instances, this is not load balanced. Some kinda workaround could be that I create prototype-scope or similar short lived scoped beans of this client and always get the "next url" for the call. This adds lots of burden to use the clients in every class I make. At least as I saw it. Maybe I could add some kind of singleton helper bean around the prototyping, but again this is not a good design as I see
I thought maybe I could create an EurekaTarget from the Target interface, but of course none of the methods indicate any "end of lifecycle" things, not even the apply method. I thought maybe that is one point which is called before doing a service call, but I saw multiple calls towards it so I had to change the url for all calls.
Do you know any better solution to do this migration?
I guess you are using Spring Boot?
The next version v1.0.0 of Resilience4j will support the #FeignClient annotation.
There was a PR which added the functionality -> https://github.com/resilience4j/resilience4j/pull/579
You can then use it as follows:
#FeignClient(name = DUMMY_FEIGN_CLIENT_NAME)
#CircuitBreaker(name = DUMMY_FEIGN_CLIENT_NAME)
public interface DummyFeignClient {
String DUMMY_FEIGN_CLIENT_NAME = "dummyFeignClient";
#GetMapping(path = "/api/{param}")
void doSomething(#PathVariable(name = "param") String param);
}
Related
I have two instances of clients with different configs that I am creating (timeout, threadpool, etc...), and would like to leverage Dropwizard's metric on both of the clients.
final JerseyClientBuilder jerseyClientBuilder = new JerseyClientBuilder(environment)
.using(configuration.getJerseyClientConfiguration());
final Client config1Client = jerseyClientBuilder.build("config1Client");
environment.jersey().register(config1Client);
final Client config2Client = jerseyClientBuilder.build("config2Client");
environment.jersey().register(config2Client);
However, I am getting
org.glassfish.jersey.internal.Errors: The following warnings have been detected:
HINT: Cannot create new registration for component type class org.glassfish.jersey.client.JerseyClient:
Existing previous registration found for the type.
And only one client's metric shows up.
How do I track both clients' metrics or is it not common to have 2 clients in a single dropwizard app?
Never mind, turned out I was an idiot (for trying to save some resource on the ClientBuilder).
2 Things that I did wrong with my original code:
1. You don't need to register Jersey clients, just the resource is enough... somehow I missed the resource part in my code and just straight up trying to register the client
2. You need to explicitly build each JerseyClientBuilder and then build your individually configured clients, then dropwizard will fetch by each JerseyClientBuilder's metrics
In the end, I just had to change my code to the following:
final Client config1Client = new JerseyClientBuilder(environment)
.using(configuration.getJerseyClientConfiguration()).build("config1Client");
final Client config2Client = new JerseyClientBuilder(environment)
.using(configuration.getJerseyClientConfiguration()).build("config2Client");
Doh.
environment.jersey().register() has a javadoc listing of Adds the given object as a Jersey singleton component meaning that the objects registered become part of the jersey dependency injection framework. Specifically this method is used to add resource classes to the jersey context, but any object with an annotation or type that Jersey looks for can be added this way. Additionally, since they are singletons you can only have one of them per any concrete type (which is why you are getting a "previous registration" error from Jersey).
I imagine that you want to have two Jersey clients to connect to two different external services via REST/HTTP. Since your service needs to talk to these others to do its work, you'll want to have the clients accessible wherever the "work" or business logic is being performed.
For example, this guide creates a resource class that requires a client to an external http service to do currency conversions. I'm not saying this is a great example (just a top google result for dropwizard external client example). In fact, I think this not a good to structure your application. I'd create several internal objects that hide from the resource class how the currency information is fetched, like a business object (BO) or data access object (DAO), etc.
For your case, you might want something like this (think of these as constructor calls). JC = jersey client, R = resource object, BO = business logic object
JC1()
JC2()
B1(JC1)
B2(JC2)
R1(B1)
R2(B2)
R3(B1, B2)
environment.jersey().register(R1)
environment.jersey().register(R2)
environment.jersey().register(R3)
The official Dropwizard docs are somewhat helpful. They at least explain how to create a jersey client; they don't explain how to structure your application.
If you're using the Jersey client builder from dropwizard, each of the clients that you create should be automatically registered to record metrics. Make sure you're using the client builder from the dropwizard-client artifact and package io.dropwizard.client. (Looks like you are because you have the using(config) method.)
I want to be involved in a reactive programming world with Spring. As I realised, it gives me a choice between two different paradigms: the annotation-based (with well-known to us #Controller, #RequestMapping) and the reactive one (which is intended to resolve an "Annotation Hell").
My problem is a lack of understanding how a typical reactive controller will look like. There are three conceptual interfaces, which I can use in my controller class:
HandlerFunction<T> (1) - I define a method for each specific ServerRequest
which returns a concrete HandlerFunction<T> instance, then register these methods with a router. Right?
RouterFunction (2) and FilterFunction (3) - Is there a specific place where all RequestPredicates with corresponding HandlerFunctions should be placed? Or can I do it separately in each controller (as I used to do with the annotation approach)? If so, how then to notify a global handler (router, if any?) to apply this router part from this controller?
It's how I see a reactive controller "template" by now:
public class Controller {
// handlers
private HandlerFunction<ServerResponse> handleA() {
return request -> ok().body(fromObject("a"));
}
// router
public RouterFunction<?> getRouter() {
return route(GET("/a"), handleA()).and(
route(GET("/b"), handleB()));
}
// filter
public RouterFunction<?> getFilter() {
return route(GET("/c"), handleC()).filter((request, next) -> next.handle(request));
}
}
And, finally, how to say that it is a controller, without marking it with the annotation?
I've read the Spring reference and all posts related to this issue on the official blog. There is a plenty of samples, but all of them are pulled out of context (IMHO) and I can't assemble them into a full picture.
I would appreciate if you could provide a real-world example and good practices of how to organise interactions between these functions.
This is not a real world example, but so far Is how I view some kind of organization on this:
https://github.com/LearningByExample/reactive-ms-example
As far as I concerned:
RouterFunction is the closest analogue to #Controller (#RequestMapping precisely) in terms of new Spring approach:
Incoming requests are routed to handler functions with a
RouterFunction (i.e. Function>). A router function evaluates to a
handler function if it matches; otherwise it returns an empty result.
The RouterFunction has a similar purpose as a #RequestMapping
annotation. However, there is an important distinction: with the
annotation your route is limited to what can be expressed through the
annotation values, and the processing of those is not trivial to
override; with router functions the processing code is right in front
of you: you can override or replace it quite easily.
Then instead of Spring Boot SpringApplication.run in main method your run server manually by :
// route is your route function
HttpHandler httpHandler = RouterFunctions.toHttpHandler(route);
HttpServlet servlet = new ServletHttpHandlerAdapter(httpHandler);
Tomcat server = new Tomcat();
Context rootContext = server.addContext("",
System.getProperty("java.io.tmpdir"));
Tomcat.addServlet(rootContext, "servlet", servlet);
rootContext.addServletMapping("/", "servlet");
tomcatServer.start();
There are both reactive and non-reactive approach. It's illustrated on Spring github
I was trying to understand the caching that happens at the client side.
Unfortunately I am unable to find any resources that can help me out.
I have employee model objects which are fairly small in size.
Once a use a GET request to obtain an employee object, I want it to be cached at the client side
Now when the request comes again to obtain the same employee, I want to see if the actual object has been modified, if not, then serve from the client cache else return the modified object also adding it to the cache.
I am using Spring boot to create a REST endpoint.
What I have been able to figure out is that cache-control would be used some how, but I am not sure how the objects would be added here in spring.
Any help here is much appreciated!!!!
Thanks,
Amar
HTTP caching is not an easy topic. There are different ways to do it, and you should probably start by familiarizing yourself with the mechanisms, this seems to be a good starting resource: HTTP caching
Then, you will probably identify some common usage patterns you will want to reuse. One way to do that is to create custom annotations and write an interceptor that reacts on them.
For example, you could write such an annotation:
#Inherited
#Retention(RUNTIME)
#Target({METHOD, TYPE})
public #interface CacheFor {
long amount();
TimeUnit unit() default TimeUnit.SECONDS;
}
and use it on controller methods like this:
#CacheFor(amount=10, unit = MINUTES)
#RequestMapping(bla bla)
public FooBar serveMyData(){
// code here
}
and in your interceptor, you will need to look at the handler method, check whether it has this annotation, and if it does, set the appropriate headers.
Is there any way to use soap-rpc web services such that the client is generated via a shared interface? Restful web services do it this way, but what about soap based? Do you always have to use a tool like Axis or CXF to generate your stubs and proxies, or is there something out there that will set it up dynamically?
Thanks.
EDIT #1:
To clarify, I'm looking to do something like this:
Common interface:
#WebService
public interface MyWebService {
#WebMethod
String helloWorld();
}
This common interface can already be used to create the server side component. My question is: can this type of common interface be used on the client side to generate dynamic proxies? Restful web services do it this way (Restlets & CXF) and it seems the .Net world has this type of functionality too.
I would see this tutorial of JAX-WS useful for your purposes:
In the example code the Web Services Client is configured by adding an annotation #WebServiceRef with a property pointing to the WSDL location to the client implementation class and no tools are needed to access the stuff from the Web Service that is referenced.
Was this the way you would like to have it, or did this even answer to right question?
Not exactly sure what you're looking for, but if you don't want to rely on JAX-WS/JAXB-generated artifacts (service interfaces and binding objects), you can make use of the Service and Dispatch APIs. For example:
QName serviceName = new QName(...);
Service service = Service.create(serviceName);
QName portName = new QName(...);
String endpointAddress = "...";
service.addPort(portName, SOAPBinding.SOAP11HTTP_BINDING, endpointAddress);
Dispatch<SOAPMessage> dispatch = service.createDispatch(portName, SOAPMessage.class, Service.Mode.MESSAGE);
SOAPMessage request = ...;
SOAPMessage response = dispatch.invoke(request);
Check Apache CXF. Configuring a Spring Client (Option 1).
When you want to call a webservice, you must have knowledge of methods implemented on it. For that, We need to make stubs OR we can read it from WSDL.
I have created a WS client, using AXIS2 libraries, which is without stubs. The thing is, for each diff. WS we need to create response handles.
You can call any WS method using SOAP envelops and handle the response.
//common interface for response handlers...
//implement this for diff. web service/methods
public interface WSRespHandler{
public Object getMeResp(Object respData);
}
//pass particular handler to client when you call some WS
public class WebServiceClient {
public Object getResp(WSRespHandler respHandler) {
...
return repHandler.getMeResp(xmlData);
}
}
Please check the link below, which shows the example interface for WS client.
http://javalibs.blogspot.com/2010/05/axis2-web-service-client-without.html
For every diff. WS method we can have diff. implementation for WSRespHandler interface, which will help parsing the response.
Not knowing java so well, but being forced to learn some to accomplish a task that I was given, I needed to consume a .Net service that I have already written, I had to do a little research.
I found that 99% of the examples/samples/problems with invoking a method call against a .Net service, or any service for that matter involved using J2EE (ServiceManager) or build classes and a proxy that reflect the service being invoked. Unfortunately for me, none of this would work. I was working "in a box". I could not add new classes, could not WSDL references, did not have J2EE, but DID have access to the standard java libs.
I am used to doing this sort of thing in pretty much every other language but java, but now there was no choice, and java it was.
A lot of digging and figuring out all new terminology, methods, classes, etc, I knew I was getting close, but was having issues with some small items to complete the task.
Then I came across this post: http://www.ibm.com/developerworks/xml/library/x-jaxmsoap/
As long as you have some sort of idea of what you need to send the soap service in term of the soap envelope, the above link will give you the information you need to be able to invoke a service without the classes, wsdl class generators and J2EE, apache or other dependencies.
In an hour from the time I read the mentioned article, I had a class working and about 10 minutes later, converted the code to the "in the box" solution.
Hope this helps
Apache Tuscany might help you, although it may be heavier than you want
http://tuscany.apache.org/
I want to build a REST Client on an android phone.
The REST server exposes several resources, e.g. (GET)
http://foo.bar/customer List of all customer
http://foo.bar/customer/4711 The customer with id 4711
http://foo.bar/customer/vip List of all VIP customer
http://foo.bar/company List of all companys
http://foo.bar/company/4711 The company with the ID 4711
http://foo.bar/company/vip List of all VIP companys
I (think) I know how to talk to the REST server and get the information I need. I would implement a REST Client class with an API like this
public List<Customer> getCustomers();
public Customer getCustomer(final String id);
public List<Customer> getVipCustomer();
public List<Company> getCompanies();
public Customer getCompany(final String id);
public List<Customer> getVipCompanies();
Referred to the presentation "Developing Android REST client applications" from Virgil Dobjanschi I learned that it is no good idea to handle the REST request in an Worker Thread of the Activity. Instead I should use the Service API.
I like the idea of having a Singleton ServiceHelper which binds to a (Local) Service but I am afraid that I did not understand the Service concept correct.
For now I do not understand how to report a REST call result (done asynchrounous in a Service) back to the caller Activity. I also wonder if I need ONE Service which handles all REST requests (with different return types) or if I need a dedicated service for each REST request.
Probably I have many other understanding problems so the best thing for me would be a sample application which meets my needs. My use case is not unusual and I hope there is in example application out there.
Would you please let me know!
Any other suggestions which points me in the correct implementation direction are also helpful (Android API-Demo does not match my use case).
Thanks in advance.
Klaus
EDIT: Similar Topics found on SO (after posting this) which lead me in the direction I need (minimizing the complex "Dobjanschi pattern"):
Android: restful API service
OverView
Edit:
Anyone interest also consider taking a look at RESTful android this might give you a better look about it.
What i learned from the experience on trying to implement the Dobjanschi Model, is that not everything is written in stone and he only give you the overview of what to do this might changed from app to app but the formula is:
Follow this ideas + Add your own = Happy Android application
The model on some apps may vary from requirement some might not need the Account for the SyncAdapter other might use C2DM, this one that i worked recently might help someone:
Create an application that have Account and AccountManager
It will allow you to use the SyncAdapter to synchronized your data. This have been discussed on Create your own SyncAdapter
Create a ContentProvider (if it suits your needs)
This abstraction allows you to not only access the database but goes to the ServiceHelper to execute REST calls as it has one-per-one Mapping method with the REST Arch.
Content Provider | REST Method
query ----------------> GET
insert ----------------> PUT
update ----------------> POST
delete ----------------> DELETE
ServiceHelper Layering
This guy will basicly start (a) service(s) that execute a Http(not necessarily the protocol but it's the most common) REST method with the parameters that you passed from the ContentProvider. I passed the match integer that is gotten from the UriMatcher on the content Provider so i know what REST resource to access, i.e.
class ServiceHelper{
public static void execute(Context context,int match,String parameters){
//find the service resource (/path/to/remote/service with the match
//start service with parameters
}
}
The service
Gets executed (I use IntentService most of the time) and it goes to the RESTMethod with the params passed from the helper, what is it good for? well remember Service are good to run things in background.
Also implement a BroadCastReceiver so when the service is done with its work notify my Activity that registered this Broadcast and requery again. I believe this last step is not on Virgill Conference but I'm pretty sure is a good way to go.
RESTMethod class
Takes the parameters, the WS resource(http://myservice.com/service/path) adds the parameters,prepared everything, execute the call, and save the response.
If the authtoken is needed you can requested from the AccountManager
If the calling of the service failed because authentication, you can invalidate the authtoken and reauth to get a new token.
Finally the RESTMethod gives me either a XML or JSON no matter i create a processor based on the matcher and pass the response.
The processor
It's in charged of parsing the response and insert it locally.
A Sample Application? Of course!
Also if you are interesting on a test application you look at Eli-G, it might not be the best example but it follow the Service REST approach, it is built with ServiceHelper, Processor, ContentProvider, Loader, and Broadcast.
Programming Android has a complete chapter (13. Exploring Content Providers) dedicated to 'Option B: Use the ContentProvider API' from Virgil's Google I/O talk.
We are not the only ones who see the benefits of this approach. At the Google I/O conference in May 2010, Virgil Dobjanschi of Google presented a talk that outlined the following three patterns for using content providers to integrate RESTful web services into Android applications...
In this chapter, we’ll explore the second pattern in detail with our second Finch video example; this strategy will yield a number of important benefits for your applications. Due to the elegance with which this approach integrates network operations into Android MVC, we’ve given it the moniker “Network MVC.”
A future edition of Programming Android may address the other two approaches, as well as document more details of this Google presentation. After you finish reading this chapter, we suggest that you view Google’s talk.
Highly recommended.
Programming Android by Zigurd Mednieks, Laird Dornin, G. Blake Meike, and Masumi Nakamura. Copyright 2011 O’Reilly Media, Inc., 978-1-449-38969-7.
"Developing Android REST client applications" by Virgil Dobjanschi led to much discussion, since no source code was presented during the session or was provided afterwards.
A reference implementation is available under http://datadroid.foxykeep.com (the Google IO session is mentioned under /presentation). It is a library which you can use in your own application.
Android Priority Job Queue was inspired by Dobjanschi's talk and sounds very promising to me.
Please comment if you know more implementations.
We have developped a library that adresses this issue : RoboSpice.
The library uses the "service approach" described by Virgil Dobjanschi and Neil Goodmann, but we offer a complete all-in-one solution that :
executes asynchronously (in a background AndroidService) network
requests that will return POJOs (ex: REST requests)
caches results (in Json, or Xml, or flat text files, or binary files)
notifies your activities (or any other context) of the result of the network
request if they are still alive
doesn't notify your activities of the
result if they are not alive anymore
notifies your activities on
their UI Thread
uses a simple but robust exception handling model
supports multiple ContentServices to aggregate different web services
results
supports multi-threading of request executions
is strongly
typed !
is open source ;)
and tested
We are actually looking for feedback from the community.
Retrofit could be very helpful here, it builds an Adapter for you from a very simple configuration like:
Retrofit turns your REST API into a Java interface.
public interface GitHubService {
#GET("/users/{user}/repos")
List<Repo> listRepos(#Path("user") String user);
}
The RestAdapter class generates an implementation of the GitHubService interface.
RestAdapter restAdapter = new RestAdapter.Builder()
.setEndpoint("https://api.github.com")
.build();
GitHubService service = restAdapter.create(GitHubService.class);
Each call on the generated GitHubService makes an HTTP request to the remote webserver.
List<Repo> repos = service.listRepos("octocat");
for more information visit the official site: http://square.github.io/retrofit/
Note: the adapter RestAdapter you get from Retrofit is not derived from BaseAdapter you should make a wrapper for it somehow like this SO question
Why is my ListView empty after calling setListAdapter inside ListFragment?
This is a little late but here is an article which explains the first pattern from the talk:
http://www.codeproject.com/Articles/429997/Sample-Implementation-of-Virgil-Dobjanschis-Rest-p
The thing I like about the first pattern is that the interface to the rest methods is a plain class, and the Content Provider is left to simply provide access to the database.
You should check out the source code for Google's official I/O 2010 app, for starters, particularly the SyncService and the various classes in the io subpackage.
Good news guys.
An implementation of the service helper is available here: https://github.com/MathiasSeguy-Android2EE/MythicServiceHelper
It's an open source project (Apache 2).
I am at the beginning of the project. I've done a project where I defined the pattern to do, but i haven't yet extract the code to make a clean librairy.
It will be done soon.